Insurance theory · page 8 of 10

Distribution

Direct sales, brokers and commission.

Distribution is how policies reach customers. Harbour Mutual sells in two ways.

  • Direct: the customer buys from Harbour Mutual itself, online or by phone. In the data, policies.broker_id is null.
  • Through brokers: an intermediary finds the customer, often compares several insurers, and places the policy. The broker is paid a commission, a share of the premium (brokers.commission_rate, 8% to 18% at Harbour Mutual).

A broker acts for the customer, an agent for the insurer; Harbour Mutual works with brokers only. Just under half of its policies in force today came through one of its 24 brokers.

Why the channel matters

  • Cost: commission is an acquisition expense; a broker-sold policy must earn it back.
  • Quality: brokers bring different customers, and their books can have different loss ratios and retention.
  • Concentration: if a few brokers bring much of the business, losing one hurts.
Judge a broker by the profit of their book, loss ratio and retention after commission, not by volume alone.

On Day 3 you will join policies to brokers and regions; on Day 6 you will rank them in a league table.

Practise it on Day 3

Check your understanding

Answer every question, then check.

1. How do you find directly sold policies at Harbour Mutual?

2. A broker's commission rate is 0.125 on a €800 premium. What is the commission?

3. Why is volume alone a poor measure of a broker?

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙

Reconnecting…

Your connection to Data Analytics SQL Lab dropped, probably a Wi-Fi blip. Hold on while it reconnects. Your work is kept.

The connection could not be restored. The page will reload in a few seconds.