Insurance theory · page 7 of 10

Claims development

Development triangles and a first look at the chain ladder.

The claims for a year keep growing long after the year ends: late reports arrive, reserves are revised, payments continue. A development triangle shows that growth, and lets an actuary estimate where it will end.

The triangle

Rows are accident years, the year the loss happened. Columns are development years: 0 is the accident year itself, 1 the year after, and so on. Each cell holds the amount paid so far, cumulated. Because later years have had less time to develop, the known cells form a triangle.

Harbour Mutual's cumulative paid claims, in euros, at 31 December 2025. You will build it on Day 6.
Accident yearDevelopment year 012
2023838,773.041,057,144.011,057,144.01
20241,790,894.102,090,776.40
20251,938,137.31

Development factors

How much does a year's paid amount grow from one development year to the next? The age-to-age factor divides the later column by the earlier one, over the years that have both:

f_{0\to1} = \frac{1{,}057{,}144.01 + 2{,}090{,}776.40}{838{,}773.04 + 1{,}790{,}894.10} = 1.197

From development year 1 to 2 only 2023 is known, and it did not grow: , because Harbour Mutual settles most claims within a year of the loss.

The chain ladder

Multiplying the latest known cell by the factors still to come projects each year's ultimate cost. For 2025:

\text{ultimate}_{2025} = 1{,}938{,}137.31 \times 1.197 \times 1.000 \approx 2{,}320{,}104

About €382,000 more is expected to be paid for 2025's losses: open claims still to be settled and claims not yet reported. That is the reserve the chain ladder suggests for 2025, on paid amounts alone.

The chain ladder assumes the future develops like the past. Three years of history make for a rough estimate; real reserving uses many years, incurred as well as paid triangles, and judgement.
Practise it on Day 6

Check your understanding

Answer every question, then check.

1. In a triangle, what is development year 0 of accident year 2024?

2. An accident year has €1.0 million paid at development year 0, and the factor to year 1 is 1.2. What is projected at year 1?

3. Why do the known cells form a triangle?

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙

Reconnecting…

Your connection to Data Analytics SQL Lab dropped, probably a Wi-Fi blip. Hold on while it reconnects. Your work is kept.

The connection could not be restored. The page will reload in a few seconds.